Paramedic and consultant case study: Prof-to-Prof clinical decisions in Tayside

We spoke with Dr Ron Cook, Consultant Emergency Physician and Jonathon Will, Specialist Paramedic for the Scottish Ambulance Service to discuss how Prof-to-Prof advice via Consultant Connect benefits patients.
Paramedic case study: rapid shared care for dementia patient - Consultant Connect

‘Utilising multidisciplinary prof-to-prof conversation along with shared decision-making, resulted in the police being reassured about their duty of care, it provided more efficient use of NHS resources, and most importantly, we absolutely got the right care for our patient.’

Paramedic and consultant case study: Prof-to-Prof clinical decisions in Tayside

Professional-to-Professional clinical decisions via Consultant Connect has been available to clinicians in Tayside Health Board in Scotland since 2018. The service rapidly connects healthcare professionals with NHS specialists for speedy and thorough advice for their patients. We spoke with Dr Ron Cook, Consultant Emergency Physician and Clinical Care Group Director for Unscheduled Medicine at Ninewells Hospital, who provides prof-to-prof advice via Consultant Connect.


Prior to the service being rolled out, what were the reservations you or your team had?

‘We didn’t have many reservations. NHS Tayside had been operating an emergency department prof-to-prof line for some time. Using Consultant Connect to support this offered the additional benefits of available data regarding call volumes and sources, and the reassurance of call recording for governance and incident review reasons.’


How have you found using Consultant Connect?

The call handling is seamless, and the dashboard and call logs are intuitive and easy to navigate. The ability to record the content of calls and access data has been a vital addition to our prof-to-prof service. Call records enable immediate ‘listen back’ which provides crucial clinical governance in reviewing decision-making and also provides a valuable educational opportunity in training staff in remote clinical decision support. Logging call volumes enables accurate resource management and contributes to job planning.’


Has your team’s workload been impacted by reviewing these cases?

‘NHS Tayside has always recognised the value of the prof-to-prof service in avoiding unnecessary presentations to ED. This long-held belief is supported by a review of call outcome data which reveals that in 30% of calls made by the ambulance service, the patient receives self-care advice or is directed to an alternative care setting than ED.’


What are the main benefits for your patients?

‘Timely availability of remote senior decision-maker guidance to enable presentation in the most appropriate care setting for that patient’s requirements, the first time.’


We also spoke with Jonathon Will, Clinical Effectiveness Lead and Specialist Paramedic for the Scottish Ambulance Service, to find out how utilising Consultant Connect to speak with specialists like Dr Cook helps him and his patients.


Patient Example

‘One example of prof-to-prof conversations working incredibly well was regarding a 74-year-old gentleman I attended. He had been reported to the police as a “wandering dementia patient”, and when they found him, it was clear he was somewhat unstable on his feet. In fact, he already had some minor injuries consistent with a fall.

‘Despite the patient’s confusion, the police managed to find out where he lived and got him home. At home, he was in a place of safety, but the police were concerned about the likelihood of repeat wandering, and possible subsequent fall. From a duty of care, they felt they needed the support of the Scottish Ambulance Service.

‘We attended and discovered that the police had contacted the patient’s brother, who was on-scene. Unfortunately, the brother was also displaying signs of cognitive decline – it was a really complex situation. The brother shared that the patient had a urinary tract infection and a recent hospital admission. The patient didn’t want to go back into hospital but also recognised that he wasn’t able to look after himself.

‘We called the prof-to-prof line via Consultant Connect, and a senior clinician informed us that the patient had been in hospital for two days for acute confusion and a UTI. There were also notes to the effect that the confusion was suspected to be more chronic in nature.

‘On the advice of the consultant, we then contacted the patient’s GP for a further prof-to-prof conversation. It transpired that the patient was booked for a five-day residential dementia assessment the following week. Given the history and our observations, the GP completed a remote consultation and prescribed further antibiotics. A prescription was sent to the local pharmacy, and we arranged for this to be collected by the patient’s own care company. The GP also provided details of the assessment centre and the patient’s social worker.

‘A conversation with the assessment centre highlighted that they could not accept the patient early, but after speaking with the social worker, we arranged emergency respite in a nearby care home to bridge the gap until his assessment.

‘Although we were on scene for a long time, our overall service time was not increased because we avoided a long convey and handover at the hospital. The patient had been quite anxious about the prospect of returning to hospital, and so he was very grateful for this alternative plan.

We avoided an unnecessary ED attendance, a probable hospital admission, we reduced travel impact, and we collaborated with our Primary Care, hospital and health and social care colleagues to provide a patient-centred plan. Consultant Connect allowed us to be more efficient with NHS resources, and most importantly, we absolutely got the right care for our patient. It was a great outcome for everyone.’


Related case studies

Perinatal Mental Health advice in Hywel Dda

Perinatal Mental Health advice in Hywel Dda

Since November 2022, health visiting and midwifery clinicians in Hywel Dda University Health Board have had access to the Perinatal Mental Health line via Consultant Connect. We spoke with the Perinatal and Infant Mental Health Service Manager, who provides advice via this line to find out about her experience.

Paramedic case study: Emergency Medicine Advice in Scotland

Paramedic case study: Emergency Medicine Advice in Scotland

Michael Muir and Keith Dickinson, Paramedics at the Scottish Ambulance Service, describe how they get Emergency Medicine advice for patients.

Telephone Advice & Guidance in Kent & Medway

Telephone Advice & Guidance in Kent & Medway

Primary Care clinicians share their experiences of how Telephone Advice & Guidance has helped improve their working methods.

5 minutes with a CMHT old age consultant and clinical director

5 minutes with a CMHT old age consultant and clinical director

Dr Funnell talks to us about her personal experience of answering Mental Health Advice & Guidance calls through the Consultant Connect service.

- Consultant Connect

Contact us

For more information about how we work with commissioners, hospitals and mental health trusts to improve patient care, please get in touch.

- Consultant Connect

Join a webinar

Listen to health experts from the comfort of your desk as we bring the experts to you in our series of online webinars.

- Consultant Connect

Join our mailing list

Join our mailing list and we'll keep you informed of our latest blogs, project news, and upcoming webinar dates and topics.

Recent tweets

Contact us


You can view our Terms & Conditions here.

Most Read Articles

Suspected Head & Neck Cancer Messaging service

The Suspected Head & Neck Cancer messaging service was launched in May 2023 to all clinicians in North Central London ICB. We caught up with the Lead Head & Neck and Thyroid Clinical Nurse Specialist who manages the line, and a GP who used the line to find out more.

read more