Advice from emergency consultants one phone call away
Advice from emergency consultants one phone call away
A feature created by HSJ in co-operation with NHS Tayside Health Board written by Jennifer Truland, HSJ.
Read this piece below or click here to view it on the HSJ. You can download a PDF version of the feature here.
A Scottish health board has rolled out a system that provides GPs and paramedics with immediate advice and guidance from emergency department consultants, reports Jennifer Trueland
Implementing a system giving GPs and paramedics access to immediate advice and guidance from consultants in the emergency department and acute medical unit is paying off for a Scottish health board.
NHS Tayside has seen a significant impact since introducing the Phone Advice & Guidance service last September, with nearly a third of calls from GPs and paramedics resulting in an avoided emergency admission.
Support is available immediately by calling a single number to reach a phone held by a consultant at the region’s main hospital, Ninewells in Dundee. Junior doctors at the smaller Perth Royal Infirmary can also use the number to source advice from a consultant out-of-hours.
GPs, paramedics and junior doctors have responded positively to the initiative, as have consultants in the ED and AMU.
Advantages include the fact that all calls are recorded, giving a real-time record of the advice that was given, improving safety and governance. GPs and paramedics also appreciate having one number to call – with the phone being answered by a senior member of the medical team, usually a consultant.
The app also allows GPs and paramedics to take photographs on their mobile phones in a safe and IG-compliant way. The photograph can then be attached to the patient record.
The service will also be trialling the real-time transmission of clinical photos and notes from remote locations back to the Ninewells emergency medicine team, which will then be accessible on screens including within the resuscitation room.
Improving the flow through emergency departments is not simply a matter of employing more staff – it’s also about making sure that everyone who attends actually needs to be there.
This is easier said than done, as shown by worsening performance against ED waiting times targets in hospitals across the UK and beyond, which also has a knock-on effect across local health and care economies.
Reshaping unscheduled care has been a key plank of transformation at NHS Tayside, one of Scotland’s 14 geographic health boards: an important part of that has involved ensuring that services, including the ED, are used appropriately.
Carol Goodman, who, in her role as general manager for the medical directorate at NHS Tayside helped spearhead the changes, says the approach has been multifaceted. “We’ve done quite a lot of work to transform unscheduled care in Tayside, which has included a really robust redirection policy,” says Ms Goodman, who is now regional programme manager for the North of Scotland region within NHS Scotland, which includes NHS Tayside.
But it also means ensuring that everyone involved in hospital admissions, from the GP making the referral to the paramedic called out to see a patient, is on board – and has speedy access to advice and support if they are not sure whether a person needs to be in hospital.
That’s where professional-to-professional advice systems come in: for several years, NHS Tayside has given GPs and paramedics the option to ring through to speak to hospital-based clinicians for decision-making support.
While this was helpful, it wasn’t ideal, with challenges including getting through to hospital switchboards at busy times, and then making contact with the relevant professional.
There was also a question of governance: the calls weren’t routinely recorded and although clinicians were supposed to write up the advice they had given in a book laid out for the purpose, this didn’t always happen. Even when it was written up, it could be some time later when the clinician had a gap between patients and other work.
One number to call
In September 2018, NHS Tayside introduced Consultant Connect’s Phone Advice & Guidance service. This gives paramedics and GPs one number to call, getting them straight through to a senior clinician – usually a medical consultant – in the ED or AMU, bypassing the need to go through switchboard or bleep the doctor on call. Importantly, the calls are recorded, giving a real-time and accurate record of the advice given.
Emergency medicine consultant Ron Cook, who is also clinical care group director for urgent care at NHS Tayside, says it’s about ensuring people are treated in the best place for them.
“Not everyone should be attending the emergency department, but not everyone knows what else is available out-of-hours, for example, NHS 24, GP out-of-hours services, and pharmacists. The emergency department isn’t the general answer to all complaints – it’s not there for ‘convenience’. We try to direct patients so that they see the right person, in the right place, at the right time.”
Although it has been available in Tayside for less than a year, Phone Advice & Guidance is already notching up around 300 calls per month from paramedics, around 200 from GPs, and around 600 from junior doctors based at Perth Royal Infirmary.
“Almost a third of calls from paramedics (30 per cent) have resulted in the patient not being conveyed to hospital.”
Feedback from users has been positive and the service reported outcomes from NHS Tayside are even more impressive. Almost a third of calls from paramedics (30 per cent) have resulted in the patient not being conveyed to hospital, with a further 5 per cent being sent directly to a clinic or outpatient department.
For GP calls, around a fifth of calls resulted in the patient being treated out of hospital, while 11 per cent were sent directly to clinic or outpatient department.
For Rod Fleming, a GP in Dundee’s Erskine Practice, Phone Advice & Guidance has proved a useful source of support. He cites one case where a young mum had attended the surgery with an upper respiratory tract infection and a pain in her upper left side. “I wanted to get a chest X-ray [there is open access x-ray in Dundee] but we wouldn’t have got the report for seven to 10 days,” he explains.
Dr Fleming spoke to the AMU consultant who agreed to look at the X-ray as soon as it was done, and speak to the patient by telephone. The patient was prescribed antibiotics in case of pneumonia, which is what it turned out to be.
“It saved her having to go up to Ninewells, and meant she could stay at home. This was good for the patient, who had two small children, but also good for the health service as it meant she was managed in the community rather than in hospital.”
Mr Cook says the system is also working well for hospital consultants, who take it in turns to hold the phone (never when they are in the resuscitation team). And staff can actually see it paying off. “The last time I held the phone, when I took the third call in two hours I realised that this was the third person who wasn’t coming into hospital,” he says. “That’s a real result.”
Helping paramedics make right decisions
Jonathan Patrick, CEO, Consultant Connect
A project that enables paramedics to speak directly with ED clinicians is helping them make decisions about the best place to treat patients, easing overstretched A&E departments, notes Jonathan Patrick
What’s the most terrifying job in the world? I think it’s “junior paramedic” or “emergency medical technician” to use the proper title. I can’t think of many jobs where the decisions you make are so fraught with meaning and consequence as they are when you are an EMT.
At the beginning you’re likely to join as an apprentice and have on-the-job training for 12-18 months, after which you’ll be a qualified EMT. At this stage you are qualified to be a single responder to an incident.
Just think about that for a moment – after as little as 12 months training, you’re now involved with life or death decisions. And the NHS staffing crisis means that you are sometimes the only medic on the scene at the most serious, category 1 callouts.
“EMTs and paramedics get to learn on-the-job from senior clinicians and get to sleep at night, knowing their decisions were the right ones.”
The only sensible way to manage the risk might be to get all your patients to hospital as quickly as possible. But that, of course, adds pressure to overstretched accident and emergency departments. In which case, you need clinical support to give you the confidence to make decisions not to convey.
Our project at Ninewells Hospital in NHS Tayside has done just that. By allowing EMTs and paramedics to speak directly with ED clinicians, nearly a third of patients are avoiding hospital and being advised to make a GP appointment, see a pharmacist or take advantage of other appropriate local options.
This is far better for them – and for the NHS. But it’s also better for the EMTs and paramedics, who get to learn on-the-job from senior clinicians and who get to sleep at night, knowing their decisions were the right ones.
Case study: Using telehealth to improve emergency care
Access to Phone Advice & Guidance helped a paramedic speak directly to a senior clinician and make a time critical decision for a patient, reports Jennifer Trueland
When Keith Dickinson was called to see a patient with a severe pain in his groin, he faced a dilemma. A paramedic with 18 years’ experience, he suspected that the patient – an older man – had a strangulated hernia and would require immediate surgery in the region’s biggest hospital, Ninewells in Dundee.
The problem was that under local guidelines, he was supposed to take surgical patients (with the exception of abdominal aortic aneurysm) to the smaller Perth Royal Infirmary for assessment.
“The situation was time-critical, and I needed to request permission to bypass PRI and take the patient straight to Ninewells,” explains Mr Dickinson, who works for the Scottish Ambulance Service and is based in the small semi-rural town of Crieff in Highland Perthshire.
Fortunately for that patient, Mr Dickinson had access to Phone Advice & Guidance, which enables him to speak directly to senior clinicians working in emergency and acute medical units.
“On this occasion, I was able to ring through and speak to a senior consultant at Ninewells and share my concerns. We agreed to bypass Perth and go straight to Ninewells, which meant the patient could be seen and treated more quickly,” says Mr Dickinson.
“As paramedics we have a lot of experience in assessing patients, but it is reassuring to know we have a strong support network in place”
“For me as a paramedic it is good to be able to get straight through to a senior doctor who understands the geography, the challenges of the environment, local guidelines, and the skills and treatments that we can offer.”
Before the new system was implemented last year, he had the option to contact Ninewells and ask for advice, or to source information from PRI, local GP services, or from ambulance control, but he feels Phone Advice & Guidance is better.
“Sometimes you had to wait a long time to get an answer from Ninewells, but with the new system, the senior consultant is on the end of a phone. That’s priceless, especially when you’re dealing with time-critical patients.”
Paramedics also have access to a system that allows them to take a photograph of a patient and get immediate advice from a senior clinician. “They say a picture paints a thousand words, and it’s so much easier if the doctor can actually see what I’m trying to describe, for example a complicated fracture,” says Mr Dickinson. “In the past it would have been difficult to do this safely because of patient confidentiality.
Related case studies
This feature, created by HSJ in co-operation with Luton & Dunstable University Hospital, shares key ingredients for meeting the Four-Hour A&E target successfully.
A GP in North East Essex CCG used Phone Advice & Guidance to get A&G from the Cardiology Team at her local trust, resulting in an admission avoided for an elderly patient.
Dr Manmit Kaur, a consultant on the National Consultant Network, answers a GP's Phone Advice & Guidance call - avoiding unnecessary referral for a patient with long history of body pain.
Dr Catherine Napper, a locum GP in Bath and North East Somerset CCG, explains why she thinks using the PhotoSAF feature on the Consultant Connect App is beneficial to both her patients and herself.
For more information about how we work with commissioners, hospitals & mental health trusts to improve patient care, please get in touch.
Join a webinar
Listen to health experts from the comfort of your desk as we bring the experts to you in our series of online webinars.
Join our mailing list
Join our mailing list and we'll keep you informed of our latest blogs, project news, and upcoming webinar dates and topics.
Most Read Articles
Writing a strong NHS business case for Advice & Guidance can make all the difference. That’s why we are sharing this real-life example.read more
We have recently been working with NHS Dorset CCG to create a free guide for taking the best photos for Teledermatology. Read on to find out more.read more
When the NHS LTP was published we recommended that local commissioners and Trusts could approach the challenge by looking for the easiest bits of the plan to gain quick, high-impact wins. Nine months on, we reflect on these recommendations.read more
One of the biggest challenges for hospitals delivering an Advice & Guidance service is staffing it – particularly during winter. The good news is that there’s now a way you can “switch on / switch off” additional consultant resource this winter.read more
Just a few weeks ago, we were included in the “rethinking referrals” part of the Neurology handbook. You can access the full handbook here.read more
The 8 NHS areas described below have one thing in common - they've all made it radically quicker for clinicians, paramedics etc. to communicate about patients using telephone and photo Advice & Guidance. Click here to download a PDF version of this article. ...read more
Consultant Connect Ltd
One St Aldates, Oxford, OX1 1DE
Company registered in England & Wales.
Company number 09488206
01865 261 467